• 0 Posts
  • 331 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 6th, 2023

help-circle











  • Feathercrown@lemmy.worldtoComic Strips@lemmy.world•Convenient
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 months ago

    I don’t really think that makes the critique fall apart, it’s just referring to a different situation than you are thinking of.

    Someone who is in a vulnerable position* has the right not to discuss politics with strangers. I don’t think discomfort (as opposed to real danger) is a great reason, but fine, whatever. They should still understand it and vote accordingly, but refusing to discuss it is sometimes necessary.

    Someone who is in a position of social power* and refuses to use it to help others by addressing other people’s real issues is complicit in whatever system they continue to accept and often vote for. Again, the primary duty here is understanding and voting: refusal to learn about how politics is important and in what ways it affects people, and vote accordingly, is morally wrong. It may still be necessary not to talk about it sometimes, but when and where you have the power to do so, choosing not to speak allows an unjust system to exist uncontested.

    *with the understanding that this changes based on context

    when people do have the social capital to spend on supporting those who can’t easily express their views, they should take the time to understand and help them politically

    Who the fuck says they’re not?

    If the OP is read as an overall refusal to engage politically rather than about discussions specifically, which seems to be their point, then the OP does? And I would agree. Plenty of people use their social power to help others, but those who refuse to engage politically are much less likely to do so, and this harm deserves to be understood and avoided.

    Do you think it’s your job to audit someone else’s life, to see if they’re doing enough and for the right people to meet some bar you’ve set for sufficient political engagement? It’s none of your fucking business.

    Uh, no, it’s everyone’s business. Politics sets the rules by which society is allowed to operate. It’s the most invasive, everyone’s-business topic there is. The only bar there is, is “care a little bit about other people”. Yes, I will make it other people’s problem if they refuse to do that-- I would consider that the “bare minimum” (I hate using that term, it’s misused so often) to participate in society.


  • Feathercrown@lemmy.worldtoComic Strips@lemmy.world•Convenient
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 months ago

    Literally what’s happening in OP’s comic.

    “I don’t do politics” could mean a lot of things. It usually means they don’t discuss it, but it also often means they don’t participate or know much about it.

    I’m not saying you need to endanger yourself by talking about politics in situations that vould get you hurt. Almost the opposite, actually-- I’m saying that when people do have the social capital to spend on supporting those who can’t easily express their views, they should take the time to understand and help them politically.



  • Feathercrown@lemmy.worldtoComic Strips@lemmy.world•Convenient
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    2 months ago

    Are your views stupid or is the other person stupid? The answer will reveal the solution to this issue.

    Unironically though, saying you don’t do politics because you want to avoid conflict is a form of the privilege OP is talking about. Choosing to avoid politics to save yourself mild discomfort can have life-threatening effects on others. Saying you don’t want to discuss it is fine, but if that causes you to become uninformed it’s probably not wise for your effect on societal health.



  • Ok, again, you are free to believe Biden and Trump’s administrations are comparable, but as someone who had to live through both admins, they really aren’t. You provided counterpoints which mostly did not address any of my claims, instead pointing out unrelated things I made no claims about, and made somewhat viable arguments against three of my many points-- still not actually pointing out anything Biden did worse, by the way, just things he did that were bad but that either aren’t what I actually claimed (the immigration article) or that he did less than Trump (DB access, federal land). To say that this makes your view the “correct” one is ridiculous.

    Then why are you supporting them, and fighting against people who are accurately pointing out that they are monsters?

    Because I don’t think it’s accurate.


  • Literally how is that moving the goalposts? I said that while Biden did bad things, it was not on the scale of what Trump did during his admin, and presented a list of specific claims I said Trump did above and beyond what other admins such as Biden’s did. You disagreed, so I asked for proof of Biden doing any of the specific things I claimed. You provided evidence of Biden doing many horrible things, like previous admins did, but did not provide evidence of him doing anything I listed. I’ve been perfectly consistent. Can you describe how you perceived the goal as moving?

    (Also, I’m not a liberal.)

    Yeah, it is important. While Trump is a 9/10 monster, Biden is only an 8/10 monster, who supports Trump, and helps him out with his projects.

    You are free to view it that way, but it would be unreasonable to claim that is the only way to view it in light of the many differences I pointed out.