• jj4211@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 months ago

    Note a key point of contention is how the training data is used and whether it is effectively discarding copyright. If you invested time making an open source project to do something people appreciate and you get attribution as a result, you may be unhappy that a model trained on your stuff can let a user prompt up an embedded implementation of what your project does without any attribution.

    This pretty much applies to all models. No one limited training data to explicitly public domain stuff.

    • BJW@lemmus.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 months ago

      You might not appreciate it, but if it’s posted online then it’s no different from someone else learning to code from reading the project. It’s not making copies of the code, it’s just strengthening the weights on a neural network. Sure, if the code is so obscure that nothing else is like it then it’s possible to get the model to regurgitate some of it due to having so few relevant sources, but it’s very unlikely to be comprehensive enough that it’s violating any copyright. If a court finds that to be the case, for some fictitious example, then I’m certain they can find an agreeable resolution to the isolated case.

      However, none of that is justification for just writing off the technology entirely. Pandora’s Box has been opened. The genie isn’t going back in the bottle. You can’t close the barn door, all the cows already escaped. What do you think boycotting it will accomplish? What exactly is the goal by figuratively sticking your fingers in your ears and pretending the models don’t exist?

      • jj4211@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        4 months ago

        I have seen this argument before and it doesn’t make sense even in theory.

        I used to work at a company that did open source work and also proprietary work with third party closed source code. The company didn’t let anyone who had seen proprietary code contribute to open source, because they felt once a person ‘learned’ from a proprietary codebase, then it’s too risky if similar looking code lands in a project.

        Imagine if someone saw the source code for Excel. Then sometime later they notice that Calc didn’t have a feature that Excel did, and contributed an implementation of the feature. Even if they hadn’t been looking directly at the Excel source code in the moment of implementation, you think Microsoft would be so “understanding” when they see someone that once worked on Excel contributing what could be construed as infringing?

        The AI companies also seem to acknowledge this, as they have offerings that promise not to use your proprietary code as training fodder. If it is not a risk of infringement, then why would it matter to promise that the proprietary code is kept out of training data? Though it was short lived, why would OpenAI have even made a deal to license Disney material if it’s all fair use anyway? If this sort of stuff is fair game, why do they get so pissy when other companies distill models?

        Even as the AI company’s have roughly defended this scenario, their defense should be a cause for concern for users. Generally they say that anything they do with things they can read is ‘fair use’, and when exhibits of clearly infringing outputs are given, they respond with the model only did that because the user’s prompt directed it, and thus the responsibility for infringement should be with the AI user, not the engine that produced the infringing output. So the possibility of an unwitting infringement is possible as the AI companies explicitly say it’s the fault of the user even if it happens.

        But we come to your last point, that essentially at this point, the whole thing is ‘too big to fail’ and thus the practical risk is low. Which is true. It’s just a bit disheartening that these companies are given free reign to interpret intellectual property law whichever way is convenient in the moment.